Guess I'm back to this again. Are you saying I ought to have reached the same unalignment level between you and fen by now? Is that what this is about?

 

Feel like the fact that you want me to flip overnight means I won't, and I'm going to have to go full tryhard on d2 to nail people into the ground, and it already sounds exhausting.

 

I don't know who you're talking to re: activity expectations.

I don't have any, I know the FS game was a one-time thing.

I just want dead mafia and a town victory.

 

I guess I assume it has to be an activity thing, because I'm town and you still aren't quite getting there on me.

 

I feel both of these things in my soul.

 

We can talk about it later.

My reasons will be so good, you'll self-vote.
--- Post automerged ---
I guess you could try looking at your posts from the POV of someone who doesn't know your alignment and think about what you see.

No need to actually post it now.

 

fonti
Newcomb
Gemma
Vaimes
Eido
M Plus 7
Stanari
Regfan
Tsaiah
Miner
Kai
Beru
Nothing Happens
Citrus
Nego
Fen

I don't think much of that is outside the consensus enough to be worth overly explaining. I'm sold on the top five. Yes, that includes eido. I think reg is probably just town and both Gemma and Miner are overreacting, but I'm not, like, sure of it. Reg down should be looked at d2.

 

I started writing reads and then every read was like "I don't have explicit reasoning and probably wouldn't stand on this read but it's there anyway".

 

I neither think that the gamestate is mafia collapse syndrome nor that the wolves are in a fine spot. Don't read too much into it, lmao.

 

Gemma - Kind of just blindly sheeping Reg/Eido here. I don't think they're w/w which means at least one of them is a villager and not with her. Gemma's an interesting mix of having taken a lot of twists and turns and having relatively high volume and engagement, but not actually much presence. Definitely someone I've put off trying to develop an independent read on, and if I'm around D2 I'll probably take a whack at that. Don't really have any advice here.

Jan - Pretty strong town read. Despite him staying somewhat on the periphery of the game, he's had a few moments where he's put down pretty much exactly what I've been thinking, which is historically a pretty decent sign. Basically, he's being proactive in this game where he doesn't really need to be as a wolf.

KaiDASH - Could be a case of just, tiny sample size overreaction, but his "lynch me early so my mislynch doesn't hurt the game too much" thing rang pretty genuine. I have zero trouble imagining Kai not being into this game at all and this being how he's playing as a villager. Kiiiind of think as a wolf he'd have done... a tiny bit more? Not a lot more, but something. Especially if fenwicked's a wolf.. like, you know that replacement is coming, probably before the thread does, and you know where the wagons are probably going to go. Would be pretty surprised if Kai/fen were w/w here. D2... idk. If anyone can figure out how to engage Kai in a way that gets him into the game, let me know. He either will or he won't, I think. If he's a villager, there's some value in just vigging him or something to take away the distraction, but I kind of quixotically think that maybe he is a villager and maybe I can get there later in the game.

M Plus 7 - Started off playing a pretty classic "highposting villager talking to/about everyone" game. Think the brief tantrum he threw and then instant contriteness would be a pretty neat bit of work as a wolf. Feels like someone who'd kinda collapse later in the game if a wolf, but that's based on just a general gut feel about his playstyle. There was one post he had that I think really sang villager, can't be assed to look it up right now but it hit a lot of super pure notes.

Miner - I think the most compelling point for Miner villager here is the disconnect between how he perceives his play and the reality of how it's being perceived by the thread at large. Like... wolves on the whole have a pretty big vested interest in understanding how they're being perceived. Granted, at this point it's almost reading like willful ignorance, which... kinda would be a wolf thing, but gun to my head I don't think that's what it actually is. The salt/snarkiness is more baffling than anything else, and the "I can't read these people because I don't know their ranges" is... something. "Teams that make sense with Miner on them" might be an interesting avenue to walk down D2, as this feels pretty restrictive and potentially a way to read him via negative space.

 

I feel really really gross that you just put me in that sentence with Miner.

 

Miner and Gemma are nothing alike, but are in this same sentence.

 

Shrugarino.

I forgot Jan. He's in the top group somewhere.

 

A part of me thinks that Beru is just mafia and asked me that question about the 3 of them being town in the hopes that I would devolve into tinfoil like that other game we were in together.

 

{MP7, Gemma} {Jan?}
Newcomb
{Regfan?} {Miner?}

Beru, Vaimes
Kai

Citrus, Nego
Tsaiah, Nothing Happens


Very Specifically Off To The Side: Eido, fonti


People in bracketed groups represent reads that aren't comparable but which have roughly the same net towniness.

 

Fuck off. I don't even scumread Regfan, I just think he has mafia equity in a town Beru world.

 

Meh. I have been fairly disconnected from the game in a way on purpose and i don't want to leave a trendy readslist because of that.
I doubt i will die tonight for reasons and things should be looking up tomorrow onwards.

Fonti you should consider letting me on your playing field.

Goodluck and have fun.
Always have fun.

 

Vaimes (1): fenwicked (#317)
fontisian (1): KaiDASH (#821)
KaiDASH (2): Nothing Happens (#291), Citrus (#1220)
Beruru (2): Regfan (#1291), Newcomb (#1311)
fenwicked (10): M Plus 7 (#1452), Nego (#1504), fontisian (#1512), Vaimes (#1585), Jan (#1619), Beruru (#1621), Stanari (#1654), Eidolonic (#1655), Gemma (#1659), Miner (#1685)

Abstaining (1): tsaiah

 

...that was just a bit of wordplay, Gemma. Putting the two names in the same sentence in something nonsensical/irrelevant <3

 

Wait ugh Miner moved.

Whatever, you guys can count right?