1. DLP Flash Christmas Competition + Writing Marathon 2024!

    Competition topic: Magical New Year!

    Marathon goal? Crank out words!

    Check the marathon thread or competition thread for details.

    Dismiss Notice

  2. Hi there, Guest

    Only registered users can really experience what DLP has to offer. Many forums are only accessible if you have an account. Why don't you register?
    Dismiss Notice
  3. Introducing for your Perusing Pleasure

    New Thread Thursday
    +
    Shit Post Sunday

    READ ME
    Dismiss Notice
DLP Story Competition Guest User Registration Nag SPS + NTT

Search Results

Search Again
Page 1 of 2
  1. Moridin
    Post

    WitchHunt #5

    Huh. Oh well, good game. I guess I owe you an apology, Snowvon. Well played, scum.
    Post by: Moridin, Oct 7, 2015 in forum: Little Italy
  2. Moridin
    Post

    WitchHunt #5

    Let's say Prophylaxis kills Tempus. I'm fairly certain the latter at least is a witch, so that should leave us with one more (if Proph does this then obviously he's not scum). Moridin Waco Newcomb Menace I'm assuming Newcomb is town because that makes the most sense to me in our current gamestate. Menace seems like the best shot at being scum here. I don't think it makes sense to say Waco was fake killed on N2, scum had no way of knowing the events that would follow so it doesn't add up....
    Post by: Moridin, Oct 6, 2015 in forum: Little Italy
  3. Moridin
    Post

    WitchHunt #5

    So... your new scumteam is Menace/Waco/??? Who fills that third slot? Me or Prophylaxis? Lovely. Prophylaxis: I'm currently a little busy, but I'm trying to think through the repercussions if you fire on Tempus today, in terms of how that would work out for the final scum (if it isn't you, obv). ---------- Post automerged at 08:30 AM ---------- Previous post was at 08:28 AM ---------- Tempus: You want to explain how both Snowvon and Fontisian are town? What's your world then?...
    Post by: Moridin, Oct 6, 2015 in forum: Little Italy
  4. Moridin
    Post

    WitchHunt #5

    Eh, at this point I like Prophylaxis more than Menace for the fourth slot. Also, disregard my last paragraph in the previous post.
    Post by: Moridin, Oct 6, 2015 in forum: Little Italy
  5. Moridin
    Post

    WitchHunt #5

    In a scum!Fontisian world, there's no way she hits Luckylee. In Menace/Newcomb/Fonti, Prophylaxis dies and scum come into this game 4v3 with town having lost the only player who can control the lynch. Given Fontisian town, it's almost certain Snowvon is scum. Ergo, Tempus is scum. Why push Snowvon town? To push Newcomb/Menace again? I'm having a hard time thinking of worlds where both Snowvon and Fonti were town. And if Tempus is scum, then no. We lynch Tempus, we get two NKs, that's...
    Post by: Moridin, Oct 6, 2015 in forum: Little Italy
  6. Moridin
    Post

    WitchHunt #5

    Why does the guy in your avatar have a boob window with a butt sticking out of it?
    Post by: Moridin, Oct 2, 2015 in forum: Little Italy
  7. Moridin
    Post

    WitchHunt #5

    1.Lungs->Prophylaxis - Tempus Fugit #998 - Unvote #1030 2.Font. - Snowvon #978 3.Menace. 4.Luckylee. - Luckylee #1079 - Snowvon #1081 5.Snowvon. - Newcomb #1033 - Unvote #1078 6.Waco. 7.Tempus Fugit. 8.Newcomb. - Snowvon #986 9.Moridin. - Snowvon #1082 Snowvon (4) - Font, Newcomb, Lucky, Moridin That's where we stand right now, by my reckoning. Vote Lynch: Snowvon
    Post by: Moridin, Oct 2, 2015 in forum: Little Italy
  8. Moridin
    Post

    WitchHunt #5

    Wait, wtf happened to Ruckyree?
    Post by: Moridin, Oct 2, 2015 in forum: Little Italy
  9. Moridin
    Post

    WitchHunt #5

    Kalas almost certainly wasn't lying about his role.
    Post by: Moridin, Oct 2, 2015 in forum: Little Italy
  10. Moridin
    Post

    WitchHunt #5

    Plus, you know, if Waco/Lucky used the Illusion Kill last night, how did Waco survive N2?
    Post by: Moridin, Oct 2, 2015 in forum: Little Italy
  11. Moridin
    Post

    WitchHunt #5

    Am I missing something? We have nine live players, so it's not mylo.
    Post by: Moridin, Oct 2, 2015 in forum: Little Italy
  12. Moridin
    Post

    WitchHunt #5

    Fonti as scum doesn't make sense in a world where Newcomb isn't her partner. Like, why give the town judge an extra life? That's about the worst person outside of the priest for scum to aim at in that particular scenario. ---------- Post automerged at 09:45 AM ---------- Previous post was at 09:43 AM ---------- Wait, why is the game ending? So who is the actual DoB? If the witches used the fake kill on Lucky, that wouldn't stop Waco's actual shot (as the hunter). The only way...
    Post by: Moridin, Oct 2, 2015 in forum: Little Italy
  13. Moridin
    Post

    WitchHunt #5

    Well, we couldn't have it too easy now could we.
    Post by: Moridin, Oct 2, 2015 in forum: Little Italy
  14. Moridin
    Post

    WitchHunt #5

    2. Well, (leaving aside the fact that I woke up after fluff's claim, which was after all 15 minutes into Day start) scum knew that they didn't have the inquisitor, which meant that they couldn't hide Atum's reality for long. If he was town, he'd have died for sure (a chance at getting town to lynch him after he's had a night check is not worth passing up the chance to kill the priest or at minimum take away his support). Given his actions on D1, even knowing he was town wouldn't have helped...
    Post by: Moridin, Oct 2, 2015 in forum: Little Italy
  15. Moridin
    Post

    WitchHunt #5

    So... you think Waco is scum, then? Fonti: what do you want to look into?
    Post by: Moridin, Oct 2, 2015 in forum: Little Italy
  16. Moridin
    Post

    WitchHunt #5

    Heh. Heheh. Hahahahaha. HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA. So I read back through the game, as I remembered the plan being iff Newcomb scum then save Lucky at one point, and wondered if that might not be the source of the confusion. Nope, Koalas was there and confirmed he understood the plan well after Fonti laid it out. As such, that option (of the angels being confused and trying to scumfirm Newcomb and Meance instead of Snowvon) is out. Which leaves either Snowvon being scum or Waco/Lucky being scum....
    Post by: Moridin, Oct 2, 2015 in forum: Little Italy
  17. Moridin
    Post

    WitchHunt #5

    Quick question here. I assume the last part means, if Lucky strays off script then he's scum otherwise he's town. The latter doesn't necessarily imply that Newcomb is scum, right? So how do we clear Newcomb? Or, for that matter, scum/scum. Not likely, sure, I trust Newcomb, but it's a possibility, and we're quickly running out of those. Scum!Newcomb could play this plan, sacrifice his teammate, and ride the towncred to the end. Given the rest of his play, it's extremely unlikely, but...
    Post by: Moridin, Sep 29, 2015 in forum: Little Italy
  18. Moridin
    Post

    WitchHunt #5

    Correctly, huh, Snowvon. So you're cruising on town's coattails to victory, but not to town's victory. SNOWVON SUPERSCUM CALLED IT. Plan looks good to me, but then I'm not good enough with mechanics to spot any flaws. Newcomb's seemed townish so far, though, so depending on the Hunter reveal I think we should be fine with this.
    Post by: Moridin, Sep 29, 2015 in forum: Little Italy
  19. Moridin
    Post

    WitchHunt #5

    Okay, I see what you mean Waco. Tempus, if you didn't have concrete evidence why did you want to push for a Cobalt lynch?
    Post by: Moridin, Sep 28, 2015 in forum: Little Italy
  20. Moridin
    Post

    WitchHunt #5

    Except why would Cobalt flip anything? He'd be the dead Gravedigger and Tempus would be his replacement, so any flip would be Tempus' to construct anyway, which means linking the two seems unlikely to help affect our view of his alignment.
    Post by: Moridin, Sep 28, 2015 in forum: Little Italy
  21. Moridin
    Post

    WitchHunt #5

    Roses are red, violets are blue. Boss, that's the target. He's coming too?
    Post by: Moridin, Sep 26, 2015 in forum: Little Italy
  22. Moridin
    Post

    WitchHunt #5

    Lynch Vote: Atum
    Post by: Moridin, Sep 26, 2015 in forum: Little Italy
  23. Moridin
    Post

    WitchHunt #5

    Well, the problem is that there's nothing to really do. Atum seems to have given up on saying anything, likely to avoid tying himself down to anyone in particular. Cobalt is following a less drastic version of the same policy. At least Kalas and Menace have posts and have been trying to participate. Aaand big Snowvon post to prove me wrong. Well, that's what I get for being defeatist. I agree with your five picks for the most part, with the caveat that I'm not so sure that Cobalt is scum,...
    Post by: Moridin, Sep 25, 2015 in forum: Little Italy
  24. Moridin
    Post

    WitchHunt #5

    ... I should have seen that coming, I guess. Serious answer?
    Post by: Moridin, Sep 25, 2015 in forum: Little Italy
  25. Moridin
    Post

    WitchHunt #5

    Hey, Lucky, wanna play patty topscumpicks? Don't say Kalas. I mean, you can if you want to, but don't only say Kalas.
    Post by: Moridin, Sep 25, 2015 in forum: Little Italy
  26. Moridin
    Post

    WitchHunt #5

    The problem with getting others to post is the dead certainty that we're lynching Atum today. Which, yeah, but it's still a detriment to motivating people to post. One of us will be dead tomorrow (at least), so... There's reason enough for scum!Jan to pull the gambit he did even if he considered he would die, but it's likelier that Jan was town. Of course, Cobalt being right about his alignment (or his role) isn't a townfirm either way. I don't think anyone's going to ease up on Cobalt or...
    Post by: Moridin, Sep 24, 2015 in forum: Little Italy
  27. Moridin
    Post

    WitchHunt #5

    Eh, I'd like to see Kalas' take on it anyway, and I don't think it's helpful to tell Atum to discard the possibility that he's town, so /shrug
    Post by: Moridin, Sep 24, 2015 in forum: Little Italy
  28. Moridin
    Post

    WitchHunt #5

    Yeah, that's true, but consider it anyway. You can also throw in an analysis of a world with scum!Atum and scum!Cobalt if you like (or town!both for completeness sake). ---------- Post automerged at 11:33 PM ---------- Previous post was at 11:32 PM ---------- So yeah, in scum!Atum town!Cobalt and scum!Cobalt town!Atum worlds, was essentially what I asked.
    Post by: Moridin, Sep 24, 2015 in forum: Little Italy
  29. Moridin
    Post

    WitchHunt #5

    Guys? Hello?
    Post by: Moridin, Sep 24, 2015 in forum: Little Italy
  30. Moridin
    Post

    WitchHunt #5

    In a scum!Kalas world, well, aside from Atum (who I believe is scum independently) I would say Tempus Fugit is the most likely to be his teammate. As I've said before, his post on Tempus felt like he was trying hard to build something to accuse him of, and then it's followed by #641. Contextually, IIRC that post itself was brought on by Fonti townreading Tempus, so it feels like he's trying to get others to show why Tempus is town, as well as distancing the two of them. Tempus also scumreads...
    Post by: Moridin, Sep 24, 2015 in forum: Little Italy
  31. Moridin
    Post

    WitchHunt #5

    his fluffiness: That's at me?
    Post by: Moridin, Sep 24, 2015 in forum: Little Italy
  32. Moridin
    Post

    WitchHunt #5

    Sure. I'm speaking in a holistic sense, it doesn't have to tie into Atum so long as it doesn't work against him. To rephrase: in a world in which Atum is scum, who else is a scumread for you?
    Post by: Moridin, Sep 24, 2015 in forum: Little Italy
  33. Moridin
    Post

    WitchHunt #5

    I think regardless of Cobalt's alignment I'm leaning towards Jan being town based on the way day ended. Him being Gambler is a less useful role for scum to lie about because the Gambler isn't protected from lynches - it's possible that scum!Cobalt wants to hide the fact that Jan was an information role, but, well, why? (Serious question) Also, there's no incentive for anyone to really post or do anything because of the way this day is evolving. We have a predetermined lynch and are speeding...
    Post by: Moridin, Sep 24, 2015 in forum: Little Italy
  34. Moridin
    Post

    WitchHunt #5

    Hammer is unanimous - 1. I think we're safe in that regard.
    Post by: Moridin, Sep 22, 2015 in forum: Little Italy
  35. Moridin
    Post

    WitchHunt #5

    6 hours to day end, and I won't be back before then. Vote Lynch: Atum
    Post by: Moridin, Sep 22, 2015 in forum: Little Italy
  36. Moridin
    Post

    WitchHunt #5

    There's no flip on death.
    Post by: Moridin, Sep 22, 2015 in forum: Little Italy
  37. Moridin
    Post

    WitchHunt #5

    I'll go over Citrus' posts again in a bit. What do you mean by your last point?
    Post by: Moridin, Sep 22, 2015 in forum: Little Italy
  38. Moridin
    Post

    WitchHunt #5

    You didn't mention #527. If you're referring to the overall sheeping of Fonti, yes, it is a thing, but it's nowhere near as egregious as you made it seem. About half of your post talks about Citrus-Fonti interactions. What precisely are you trying to nail down there? Because that's something you neatly sidestep. With the exception of this: So do you think this makes a Citrus/Fonti team? In that case, Fonti should also be someone you're looking at. Or do you simply think that Citrus is...
    Post by: Moridin, Sep 22, 2015 in forum: Little Italy
  39. Moridin
    Post

    WitchHunt #5

    Wait, so witches do have daychat? Okay, that changes things. Off the top of my head, Cobalt and Lucky come off worse in a re-analysis. A lot of interactions between Fonti and Citrus, among others, become a little more benign. I suppose unvotes don't really count for anything, hmm. I might throw down the final vote on Atum if necessary in a bit, there's no danger of a hammer but there's also no rush. Lungs, can you expand on why you scumread Menace, and any other scumreads you have? I tried...
    Post by: Moridin, Sep 22, 2015 in forum: Little Italy
  40. Moridin
    Post

    WitchHunt #5

    No specific focus, although I would like your views on Kalas, Waco and maybe Atum.
    Post by: Moridin, Sep 22, 2015 in forum: Little Italy
  41. Moridin
    Post

    WitchHunt #5

    Okay, sorry for my disappearance. I tried to check in and keep abreast of the thread, but I've clearly failed spectacularly. I'm not sure I understand where Atum's wagon came from - the post was pretty crummy, but he got five votes in one hour (fake edit: and now another), which feels pretty strange tbh. Especially coupled with the lack of accompanying pressure to add on to his reads or anything. If I wasn't townreading Citrus I'd be really unhappy with #527 (target designated) but as it...
    Post by: Moridin, Sep 22, 2015 in forum: Little Italy
  42. Moridin
    Post

    WitchHunt #5

    In hindsight, this is a really stupid post. Not the part about Lucky, but... yeah. :facepalm
    Post by: Moridin, Sep 21, 2015 in forum: Little Italy
  43. Moridin
    Post

    WitchHunt #5

    Still a bad idea to lynch him, then. As long as whoever replaces him is made aware of what they're getting into, it shouldn't be a problem. Though Fonti's vote is probably more one of frustration than anything, I guess.
    Post by: Moridin, Sep 21, 2015 in forum: Little Italy
  44. Moridin
    Post

    WitchHunt #5

    Really? Seems like this should just push us away from that, not towards. I mean, is it just me, or does LuckyLee seem to be really invested in getting lynched today? First the unrepentant lack of content (cba to look it up but someone said 'is that all you are going to say' and he replied 'lol yeah'), then this. Lends credence to him being DoB, either scum or bored, but either way not someone we want dead D1 for all the reasons above.
    Post by: Moridin, Sep 21, 2015 in forum: Little Italy
  45. Moridin
    Post

    WitchHunt #5

    Eh, I can see scum!Lucky pulling that stunt too, it does make it that much more unattractive to lynch him.
    Post by: Moridin, Sep 20, 2015 in forum: Little Italy
  46. Moridin
    Post

    WitchHunt #5

    Okay, so on a reread I don't have all that much more. I like Citrus some more now. He took until about late page 10 to start properly contributing, but once he did he seemed pretty aggressive and engaged others, so there's that. Hopefully him defending me didn't colour my perceptions too much, but seeing as I only had him in mind to look over based on that one post I think I'm comfortable marking him down as a townread. I'm in agreement with Waco about Lucky, his readwall is meh and even...
    Post by: Moridin, Sep 20, 2015 in forum: Little Italy
  47. Moridin
    Post

    WitchHunt #5

    I think I've shown here that I'm not comfortable with people saying things like "just for that, you can be town". Plus, I don't like how he didn't address anything that was going on directly above him (specifically, the me vs Snowvon interactions). I also don't like him asking for opinions on GD claim rather than explaining his own rationale behind it (for or against). In short, he ends up popping in and not actually saying anything. Could be from either alignment depending on the role and...
    Post by: Moridin, Sep 20, 2015 in forum: Little Italy
  48. Moridin
    Post

    WitchHunt #5

    I meant asking him questions. Asking someone to post is not necessarily as constructive or revealing as pointing them to a particular issue. And yeah, I was gone for a while there.
    Post by: Moridin, Sep 19, 2015 in forum: Little Italy
  49. Moridin
    Post

    WitchHunt #5

    Hmm, I dunno. Maybe to get a reaction from someone who apparently was your strongest scumread at the time? And nice backtrack on that one, by the way. Hint: If you need him to post more, there's an easy way to arrange for that. I just went back over the thread and looked, lol. I said 'my time' because that's the timestamp it shows me, and I didn't want anyone to see something different and get confused. Stellar job so far ;) Based on the merge timestamp, it's literally been...
    Post by: Moridin, Sep 19, 2015 in forum: Little Italy
  50. Moridin
    Post

    WitchHunt #5

    Yeah... no. So.. These are serious reads? There's a disconnect there. He may RVS you all the time, but that doesn't tell us why you asked him. Specifically, him, instead of me, or Cobalt, or Fluff? Can you expand on why they are townreads for you? It's reasonable because it is the kind of stuff that gets thrown around on D1. Despite that, it feels like you are having a back and forth that is constructed around a couple of key points (the soft townfirms). I don't know...
    Post by: Moridin, Sep 19, 2015 in forum: Little Italy
Showing results 1 to 50 of 59 Next >
Search Again
Page 1 of 2