His read was not indicative and too early.

You can call me out for what you want.

If you don't want to put the time and energy into this game then get lost.

But your readslist is uncooked and I will not allow you to die with something like that.

The problem is not that the list is wrong, but the reasons are so weak that they look like fucking tmi to me.

 

So does this Fishy guy just post a one-liner once every 24 hours and that's all you get?

 

Which direction?

---------- Post automerged at 11:21 ---------- Previous post was at 11:20 ----------

It's enough. Do not lynch.

 

I have a read on Tom I believe. You're telling me it's wrong. I think you're full of shit.

Newcomb had a read on Von I agreed with. Again, you told me it was wrong.

You are fighting the towncircle, Jan.

 

I agree with him.

 

I fight for the towns i believe in.

If don't trust in uncooked hasty reads.

If i believe a read on someone is given earlier than it should be, then I will point it out, because that is a damn good scum tell 9/10 times.


I am done talking with you about this.
If you are town then you are most likely wrong on something, starting with me, which means your townread on newcomb is bad, because you read him town for not being on my team.

I will not agree with killing you ever today.
If the others do then fine, you can just be wrong and still town.
If scum kill you tonight, then i will feel no loss for this town.

I played fairly openly this game because it was supposed to be fun, the fact that you don't read me town really confuses me and fucks with my head.
I do expect you to be better than this (at least in reading me).

 

vote: fontisian

---------- Post automerged at 11:32 AM ---------- Previous post was at 11:31 AM ----------

I don't agree with fonti, but I think she might be town?
Weird but true.

 

Except that in the last game, you were happy to accept my read on people like Newcomb /because/ you knew the read was likely accurate regardless of my alignment. Here, you swapped that, and are pushing the angle that I'm wrong /even if I'm town./

Maybe if you reads were more on point I would townread you. But they're not, and you're directly fighting what I'm trying to build.

---------- Post automerged at 02:34 PM ---------- Previous post was at 02:33 PM ----------

Unvote

I am not ok with this.

If we're lynching me, it has to be because it will help you guys follow my reads. The idea that I will turn up town, and then you'll ignore some of my reads is not part of the bargain.

 

That reasoning is why I think you're town.

 

I am unconvinced the towncircle works like that in this game fonti.
Mimes don't want to fight it. They want to be in it, sure.

But the equivalent of the typical towncircle in this game is the never lynches.
That is probably me, newcomb, fishy, jan, and maybe rubicon (for some reason), though that slot is still open.

Any scum outside of that "circle" is stoked right now.
But otherwise, that's approximately the final 5. And I'm not sure it matters what order we go in to get there.
It's a weird sense of inevitability.

 

I hate you.

 

Your reasons are bullshit.

Do you think that I as scum would fight a d1 townread on Von ever?

I have him calculated as lynch/nightkill always from the get go because he is fucking Snowvon.

I fight that read because I don't think it was well times and just too early and I disliked the reasoning.
It is a reason you give because you know he is town and want to give a reason for it, not one you give on someone when you have no idea about their alignment.

Because it is von and you can just wait a day and then you will realize he is town anyway. There is no reason to make such a read this early on.

You believing that I as scum am likely to fight that read unless i truly believe it is bullshit just does not go into my hgead.
It just makes no sense.

Scum does not win by fighting a d1 townread that will ALWAYS confirm himself later on. Scum wants to be townread and therefore I as scum will like and create towncircles.

And yes you can call wifom, because you can call wifom on everything everyone does, but you might just want to use your brain.

 

Ok, let's say there's a towncircle and the mimes aren't in it. Do they have to fight to get in it? Yes. Would this fight involving going after others, some of whom are going to be in the towncircle? Of course. And would they want to try to pocket the other townies outside the towncircle who are going to be around in endgame? Hell, yeah.

 

You're doing what he did and using pronouns instead of names for them.

 

This is a fair point. We've mislynched Von, like, once.

 

And where is the difference between a mime trying to poke holes in your towncircle and a town telling you that what you are doing is most likely not working out and full of shit?

Like .. I am not fighting all your reads.

I am telling you townreads on Newcomb and Tom and not good at this point.

---------- Post automerged at 20:45 ---------- Previous post was at 20:43 ----------

On d1 because he didn't bring his towngame/mentality.

In a game like this i would have to hope that he is not capable of projecting town on 1 of 5 or 6 ingame days.

 

Semantics are the main difference.

I think Newcomb's overall behavior has been stupidly town. I could understand you at least not agreeing with the case on you, but surely you can see it in his other posts?

And your problem with the Tom thing is based on the fact that he likes to troll, but I don't think that's relevant to my case at all. I think the more important thing is that he's not motivated to appear town at all, and that as scum, he will always have some of that motivation and it will shine through.

 

This is a good point and evidence for Newcomb being a mime.

 

That historical retelling of jan fighting for town vaimes day 1 reeks of TMI btw.
This final 5 is getting harder for whoever in it is town.

 

Would you be more specific about which behavior and posts have been stupidly town?